Etsy's new terms from 16 December: what they mean for UK sellers
Share
If you sell on Etsy, you've probably had an email about the updated Terms of Use, and if you've been anywhere near Reddit or a seller Facebook group recently, you'll have seen people getting very wound up about it. I've read through the changes (and a fair few of the reactions), so I wanted to set out what's changing, what's rubbing people up the wrong way and what I'd be thinking about if I were a UK seller.
A quick note before I start: I'm a web designer rather than a lawyer, so please treat this as a plain-English summary rather than legal advice, and do read the terms yourself.

What's changing on 16 December
Etsy published new Terms of Use and an updated Privacy Policy on 26 October, and they come into effect on 16 December 2026. The change everyone's talking about is in Section 5, which covers the content you upload, such as your photos, descriptions, shop name, reviews and videos. It now says Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" can use that content to develop, train, test and improve AI and machine learning.
Etsy's UK privacy policy gives AI listing tools and AI summaries of reviews as examples of how it plans to use this, and an Etsy spokesperson has said the aim is to improve seller tools, search results and fraud detection.
There are a couple of smaller changes too. Etsy can now decide which bots and AI tools are allowed to browse or buy on the site, and if you use an automation tool on your shop, you're responsible for what it does. If you use Etsy's own AI tools, the terms also make it clear that it's up to you to check what they produce before you rely on it.
What isn't changing
- Ownership: Etsy isn't claiming ownership of your work, and the terms still say your content belongs to you.
- The licence: sellers have given Etsy a worldwide, royalty-free, perpetual licence to use, edit and reproduce their content for a long time, so the new part is that AI training is now written into it. It's possible Etsy was already allowed to do this and has now spelt it out.
- Selling your photos: there's nothing in the terms saying Etsy will sell your photos to AI companies. The new terms actually ban other companies from scraping Etsy content to train their own AI without permission.
- Two separate changes: on 22 October Etsy also published new rules on how sellers can use AI in their listings, including needing at least one real, unedited photo of the product.
What I'd be thinking about as a UK seller
- There's no off switch: the terms mention "opt-out rights", but there isn't an AI setting you can turn off. UK sellers have a general right under data protection law to object to Etsy using their personal data, which you'd send to Etsy's Data Protection Officer. Etsy then weighs up the request, and it may not cover product photos or designs, as these aren't necessarily personal data. The new wording also has you recognise Etsy's "legitimate interest" in using your content where it includes personal information, which may make an objection harder to argue.
- Deleting may not undo it: the licence is perpetual and irrevocable, so removing a listing or closing your shop may not stop Etsy using what you've already uploaded. Etsy hasn't said how it treats deleted content when it comes to AI training.
- The partners aren't named: we don't know who Etsy's "third party partners and vendors" are, or whether they can use your content for things that have nothing to do with Etsy. If you make original designs, in my opinion this is the part to keep an eye on.
- Image protection tools: a new section bans hidden content designed to manipulate or interfere with Etsy's AI tools and systems, and says this can lead to your account being closed straight away. It's aimed at things like hidden instructions in listings, but it isn't clear whether tools some artists use to protect their images from AI training, such as Glaze or Nightshade, would count. I'd check with Etsy before using them on your listing photos.
- Staying means agreeing: if you keep using Etsy after 16 December, you've accepted the new terms, and the only alternative Etsy offers is closing your account.
- The bigger picture: the terms also say Etsy can change or stop its services at any time and isn't responsible for any effect on your income. That has always been the case, and in my opinion it's a very good reason to think about having your own website regardless of the AI clause.
Why sellers are so cross
In my opinion the anger is completely understandable. Etsy is (meant to be) the home of creatives, and if there's one group of people who are getting it in the neck from AI, it's creatives. Being told your photos and designs can be used to train AI, with no way to switch it off, is a lot to swallow when you've built your business on your own work.
I also see it from the other side, as someone who used to shop on Etsy a lot and doesn't any more. It's got much harder to find genuinely handmade things among all the mass-produced, Temu-style stuff, and drop-shipping shops seem to carry on regardless. Etsy did bring in new rules on AI-generated listings in October, but a copied listing was reported just six days later, and Etsy's own executives have admitted they haven't always dealt with sellers' AI concerns as quickly as they should have. You don't get the feeling Etsy is on the sellers' side, and that's why these new terms feel like a step too far for a lot of people.
Do you need to leave Etsy?
I don't think this means everyone needs to leave Etsy, it's main draw for many is that is brings buyers to their shop - it's a ready made audience, and for a lot of small makers that's the hardest part of selling online. What I'd suggest is treating Etsy as one shop window rather than your whole business, and having your own website alongside it that you control with a view to easing off Etsy when you can. This doesn't do anything for a creative business from the new Etsy policy point of view - if you're still a seller on there after the 16th December they've got your data and can do what they want with. it.
With your own site, you own the domain, decide what goes on it, keep your own customer list and set your own policies. Saying that, you're also responsible for bringing people to it, keeping it up to date and doing the marketing, which takes time and has ongoing costs. Your own site won't stop AI tools scraping images that are publicly online either, so what it gives you is more control rather than complete protection.
It's a lot to consider for a creative trying to make a living and as far as I can see Etsy is not making things easy or good for their creative sellers. It very much feels like they're having their cake and eating it - they know that they are pivotal for so many small businesses they are pushing the boundaries of what they can get away with.
I work with a lot of creatives and understand the pressures associated with having your own website so if you want to reach out with a question or even just have a chat I'm more than happy to do that! There will likely be a few more posts about this over the next few weeks so if you'd like those straight to your inbox, you can sign up to my newsletter here.